Why it can work

Every major tradition already carries the seed of this. Nobody has to give up what formed them.

Why the traditions need each other, why this has only ever happened by accident, and what it would take to make it happen on purpose.

Every path reaches a limit

Take any serious tradition far enough and it reaches a point it cannot pass alone. That is what a path shows you once you have walked it far enough to see its edge, and it is no failure of the path.

A Buddhist practitioner who takes the teaching on the emptiness of self to its end finds that the line between self and others empties too. Individual liberation then raises a question that individual practice cannot answer. A systems scientist who models a whole civilisation finds that analysis, however good, does not tell anyone how to act wisely inside the system it describes. An elder whose community knows how to live well with one valley finds that this knowledge was built for a scale that the modern world has overrun.

These are different limits. They are the same kind of limit, reached from different directions by traditions that share almost nothing else. We take that as a signal.

People notice this, more than traditions do. Within each tradition, particular practitioners have said, in their own tradition’s language, that a wider meeting is now needed. Teilhard de Chardin said it and was silenced for it. Sri Aurobindo built a practice around it. Martin Buber made it the centre of his philosophy. The people who see it most clearly tend to be those who have lived seriously inside two traditions. Raimon Panikkar was a Catholic priest, a scholar of Hinduism and a Buddhist practitioner. Francisco Varela was a neuroscientist who found that his science needed what meditation knows.

Different instruments, not different opinions

The traditions are more like different instruments than different opinions about one reality that argument could settle. Each one is tuned to pick up things the others cannot register.

Contemplative practice notices things in inner experience that laboratory science was not designed to measure. A relational, land-based tradition notices dependencies that analytic philosophy tends to abstract away. Rational inquiry notices causal structure that mystical intuition tends to dissolve. The problems that resist every framework may need all of these at once, and no single tradition can supply that.

It has happened before

People from different ways of knowing have created something new together before. It is one of the best-documented things in human history.

In the Renaissance, classical learning, Islamic scholarship, Christian theology and early experiment met in a handful of Italian cities. The result was a way of understanding that none of them contained.

In jazz, African rhythm and improvisation met European harmony in one American city. The result was a music that neither tradition had.

In complexity science, physicists, biologists, mathematicians and economists met at the Santa Fe Institute. The result was a new science of systems.

In the Axial Age, between about 800 and 200 BCE, China, India, Persia, Israel and Greece each developed new forms of reflective thought. They did it at the same time, but separately. They never met.

Why it always stopped

Each of these happened because the people involved already shared some ground. It was doing work nobody noticed.

Florence gave scholars a city, a common language of learning and patrons who paid them. New Orleans gave musicians the same room, the same hour and the same audience every night. Santa Fe gave scientists mathematics, a language in which distant fields could talk about one thing. The Axial Age gave its traditions nothing in common, and they developed side by side without meeting.

Look at how long each took, and a pattern appears (the dates are approximate). With no shared ground, the Axial traditions never converged at all. With a city, the Renaissance took centuries. With a nightly bandstand, jazz took decades. With a shared mathematics and an institute built for the purpose, complexity science took years. The more shared ground, the faster something new appeared. None of that ground was designed.

The traditions that have never met are exactly those with no ground in common. There is no Florence for a Sufi philosopher, a Quechua knowledge holder and a climate modeller. No such place will appear by itself.

So the shared ground has to be built

That is the project in one sentence. We want to build, on purpose, the shared ground that history only ever supplied by accident.

Others have tried related things, and each stops at the same wall. We have surveyed them in The field. Today’s AI makes the problem worse by default. Ask a language model to speak as a Buddhist or a Confucian and it adopts the vocabulary while reaching the conclusions of its training data, which is mostly Western and modern. As AI becomes the way traditions are presented to each other, the flattening that has always happened in cross-cultural dialogue becomes automatic, instant and invisible. By flattening we mean one tradition’s ideas being quietly recast in another’s terms until what made them distinctive is gone. The answer is AI built to keep differences intact, not less AI.

What we’ll build sets out the system, and how we’ll prove it the test that could stop it.

What we mean by synthesis

By synthesis we mean this. People from very different ways of knowing work together long enough that they come to see something none of them could see before, and they can trace it back to the meeting that produced it.

Three marks set it apart from agreement or compromise. It is new: nobody brought it to the table. It is recognisable: each person can find their own contribution in it and is willing to put their name to it. And it is traceable: it can be followed back to the meeting that produced it. A compromise fails the first mark, a consensus nobody recognises fails the second, and an idea that would have come anyway fails the third.

We think we can see it already, in partial and accidental forms:

  • A river that is a legal person. For the Whanganui iwi of Aotearoa New Zealand the river is an ancestor: Ko au te awa, ko te awa ko au, “I am the river, and the river is me.” Western law has the idea of a legal person. In 2017 the Te Awa Tupua Act brought the two together: the river became a legal person in its own right, with two guardians, one for the iwi and one for the Crown. Neither tradition held that form before, and both can recognise themselves in it. It took a dispute that began with petitions to Parliament in the 1870s.
  • A new scientific method from contemplative practice. Francisco Varela, a neuroscientist and Buddhist practitioner, trained people to describe their own experience precisely and used their reports to read brain recordings. The reports revealed patterns the recordings alone did not show. Consciousness science tells the story and the debate around it.
  • A finding science could not make alone. The IPBES 2019 assessment, built with indigenous knowledge holders, reported how much of the world’s remaining biodiversity lies on lands indigenous peoples and local communities manage.
  • Whole new forms, by accident. Jazz and complexity science, set out above.

Each of these happened once, by accident or after generations, and none was kept in a form the next attempt could build on. What nobody knows is whether synthesis can be produced on purpose, again and again, between traditions that share no ground, and whether it accumulates. That is our hypothesis, and it has not been tested. How we’ll prove it sets out the test that will show whether it holds.

Nobody’s tradition dissolves into a common one. When the work ends in agreement, each person can find their own contribution in the result. It can also end with a disagreement that everyone finally understands, which is a result too.

The sixteen traditions

We have written an account for each of sixteen traditions, arguing from inside it why its own deepest ideas point toward this work. Between them they reach the formative traditions of most of the world’s people. On Pew Research Center’s count for 2020, Christians are 28.8% of the world, Muslims 25.6%, the religiously unaffiliated 24.2%, Hindus 14.9%, Buddhists 4.1% and Jews 0.2%, with 2.2% in other traditions.

The list is not chosen by population alone. Judaism is a small share of the world, but it holds a way of reasoning from binding precedent that the experiment needs. The census files Taoism, Shinto, Sikhism and every folk tradition under “other”, which is the flattening this project is about. The list has gaps we know about. Two pages cannot cover all indigenous peoples, and traditions with written texts are over-represented.

Each account is a starting point, written from outside so that the people who hold these traditions can take it deeper.

  • BuddhismThe Bodhisattva vow. An awakening that, followed to its end, cannot be completed alone.
  • ChristianityLove of neighbour. If the neighbour is everyone, what does love look like at the scale of a civilisation?
  • IslamKhalifa. Stewardship of a creation that includes every human being, wider than any one community.
  • Hinduism and the Vedic traditionsAtman is Brahman. If individual and universal consciousness are one, the boundary between people is thinner than it looks.
  • JudaismTikkun Olam. A repair of the world that no person or community can complete alone.
  • TaoismThe usefulness of emptiness. The empty space inside things is what makes them useful. Something new may appear in the space between ways of knowing.
  • ConfucianismTianxia. All under heaven, joined by relationships that make people fully human.
  • African traditions and UbuntuUbuntu. A person is a person through other people.
  • Indigenous traditions of the AmericasBuen Vivir. Living well means living in right relationship with the whole.
  • Indigenous traditions of North America and the PacificWayfinding. Reading wind, current, star and swell as one system, from inside it.
  • ShintoKami. The sacred met in the particular. A reminder that planetary thinking must stay rooted.
  • SikhismSeva. A scripture that gives a place to voices from other traditions, and a life built on selfless service.
  • Secular humanism and Western philosophyThe Enlightenment. Enormous knowledge, and too little wisdom about how to use it.
  • Science of systems and complexityEmergence. Wholes behave in ways their parts cannot predict. Does that apply to human thinking?
  • Consciousness scienceCollective coherence. A science of consciousness built on individual measurement may not be able to see what happens in groups.
  • Integral and evolutionary thoughtEvolution of consciousness. The maps of collective development exist. The experiment has never been run.

From the founder

For twenty-five years I have worked on moving the impact of disasters from the people who suffer them to those who can carry the financial burden and support the recovery. At its most ambitious, that work points to a reinsurer of last resort: when a disaster could bring a whole country down, the wider world stands behind it, with money and with the rebuilding. That is solidarity at its highest, organised for the hardest moments.

Our planetary problems call for the same solidarity in how we think. Every tradition carries part of them, and carries it deeply. Standing together at scale, each keeping its own way of seeing, the world’s ways of knowing can carry the whole, and give humanity an intelligence as wide as the problems it faces. The more varied the ways of knowing that stand together, the further the whole can see.

I have seen this happen in the moments that started this project. People from very different paths, working on a question hard enough to need all of them, arrived at an approach that none had brought and all could recognise as partly theirs. Those moments are the seed. WhatIfWe is built to make them deliberate, to make them last, and to bring them to the scale of the problems.

The traditions already carry what is needed. Each one, followed far enough, reaches toward the others. What we add is the ground to meet on, built with the most powerful tools of our time: AI that carries meaning between ways of knowing, and a record that keeps what each meeting reaches, so the next one begins further on.

This is the collaboration I believe the world now needs. In time it becomes the place where people from every tradition choose together which problems to take on, and work on them with an intelligence wider than any of us holds alone. I want to build it with people who have gone further than I have in ways of knowing I have not walked, and with partners who know how to build at planetary scale. I invite you to be one of them.

Hector Ibarra, founder, November 2026

Take it deeper with us

This argument is published so it can be examined and taken further. Every page is a starting point. If you hold one of these traditions, work in one of these fields, or build the kind of technology this needs, the most valuable thing you can bring now is depth: what your tradition already knows about the collective question, what a page could say more fully, and where the design could go further. Write to us, and tell us which part you would take deeper.