The field

Case study · IPBES

IPBES gave indigenous knowledge a seat beside science. How the two work together is still unsolved.

The first formal attempt to put indigenous knowledge and science on an equal footing in global policy, and what the pushback from both sides teaches.

  • Established 2012
  • 145 member states
  • Biodiversity and ecosystems

The story

IPBES, the Intergovernmental Science-Policy Platform on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services, was set up in 2012 to do for nature what the IPCC does for climate: gather what is known and put it in front of governments. From the start it tried something the IPCC had not. It gave indigenous and local knowledge standing as a parallel system of knowledge, alongside peer-reviewed science, and not as extra data.

It also wrote down how this would work. One principle is that indigenous knowledge holders speak for their own knowledge, instead of outside researchers interpreting it for them. Its 2019 global assessment reported that lands managed by indigenous peoples and local communities hold a large share of the world’s remaining biodiversity. Science alone could not have documented that. It needed the knowledge of the people managing those lands.

Both sides pushed back. Some scientists objected to non-peer-reviewed knowledge in a scientific assessment. Some indigenous communities feared their knowledge would be taken out of context and used for other people’s purposes. Both reactions point to the same thing: a real meeting between ways of knowing unsettles everyone in it.

What it shows

When indigenous knowledge is formally treated as an equal system of knowledge, the result includes findings neither side could reach alone. The discomfort on both sides is part of the evidence that the meeting is real.

Where it stops

IPBES exists to inform governments. The meeting between knowledge systems is real, but it is aimed at producing assessments. IPBES does not ask what months of such meetings do to the people taking part. The day-to-day practice of how different ways of knowing actually work on something together is still an open problem.

What it means for us

IPBES proved that the formal commitment can be made. Its most useful lesson for us is the pushback. Scientists worry about standards of evidence and knowledge holders worry about appropriation, and both worries are legitimate. Our first groups will need to work with that discomfort instead of rushing to resolve it. The questions IPBES leaves open, about what happens inside the people when the commitment is kept up over time, are the ones we want to study.