All sixteen traditions

Collective coherence

Consciousness science

A science of consciousness built on individual measurement may not be able to see what happens in groups.

The idea

If consciousness plays a part in how we meet reality, what happens when many people attend together?

What this field has built

Consciousness research now spans neuroscience, contemplative science, psychology and the philosophy of mind. It has given careful accounts of attention, of trained meditative states, and of how a person’s experience changes with practice. It has also begun to measure what happens between people. Heart rhythms fall into step among people who share a ritual. Brain activity couples between two musicians even in the silent pauses of a duet. Groups can enter a shared state of focused absorption that differs from individual focus.

Where it already reaches further, and what is still contested

Some physicists asked for this long before it became a field of research. David Bohm, who also developed a practice of group dialogue that is still used today, wrote:

“To meet the challenge before us our notions of cosmology and of the general nature of reality must have room in them to permit a consistent account of consciousness. Vice versa, our notions of consciousness must have room in them to understand what it means for its content to be ‘reality as a whole’.”

David Bohm, Wholeness and the Implicate Order (1980), introduction

Others have built a method. In 1996 the neuroscientist Francisco Varela, who was also a Buddhist practitioner, proposed what he called neurophenomenology: train people to describe their own experience precisely, then use those descriptions to read the brain data. In 2002 he and his colleagues did it. People’s trained reports of their own state sorted the brain recordings into patterns the recordings alone did not show. What a person can tell about their experience became part of the measuring instrument. The method is still debated. Some philosophers hold that a report shows what a person believes about their experience rather than the experience itself, and in 2018 a group of fifteen researchers warned that meditation research had run ahead of its evidence.

Some researchers have gone much further and claimed that collective attention or intention affects the physical world beyond the people involved. The Global Consciousness Project tracked random number generators around the world during major events. Lynne McTaggart’s Intention Experiments tested whether focused group intention changes biological systems. Joe Dispenza reports bodily changes during sustained meditative states. These claims are contested, and we say so plainly. The Global Consciousness Project’s own principal analyst concluded that its seventeen years of data do not support a collective field. A three-laboratory replication of the earlier Princeton experiments failed on its main measure.

This project claims nothing about effects outside the people taking part. What we draw from this field is narrower and solid: shared states between people are real and measurable.

Where it stops

There is no good evidence yet that a shared state lets a group think better than its members working alone. Some studies point the other way. People who chant or march in step produce less creative work together, and minority views get repeated less often. The routes to group focus that we know about tend to work by making people alike. The open question is whether a group can reach deep shared attention while staying different. A science built on measuring individuals in isolation may not be equipped to answer that. What would a science of thinking together need that current methods do not have?